Let’s disagree to disagree

Section head text.

Let’s argue!

Since our last conversation about sandbagging was so popular, let’s air out even more dirty chamois. This week – equipment, can you buy speed and/or wins? I’ve been on the receiving end of some free speed thanks to the generosity of a Zipp rep, but what about those who cannot drop $1,700 on a set of wheels? Are they at a disadvantage?

This issue seems especially relevant as we are coming into TT season. Does the strongest always win? Or can speed and strength by overcome by spending on TT equipment? Will rich guys be the only ones racing TTs?

‘Purist’ Schmalz not too proud to break out the aerobars, even with a fixie.

41 Comments

jonathan

one pro told me that 99% of cycling equipment is marketing hype but a good aero set of wheels is noticeable…in a sport where 10 meters can mean the difference between winning & not placing, it could be worth getting a cheaper frame/gruppo and really good wheels.

beergutter

At this level, the variablity of in fitness, and readiness can mean much more than any minor reduction in co-efficent of drag from a superslippy helmet or a pair of aerobars made by Ginsu to cut through the wind. The bigger issues are what else is going on in your life that prevents you from fully focusing on the TT and doing your best. *IF* there is a benefit from the expensive stuff it is the psychological benefit of some super-expensive, aero setup that makes you think yourself faster than any actual decrease in frontal area.

lee3

I’d rather have a TT helmet than a road lid covered in syran wrap. I’d also rather have dedicated TT bars w/aero shifters as opposed to clip-ons. All of these things, IMO equate to shaving clock. I’d much rather have a dedicated TT rig for the Stage race events also. Nothing is worse than having to tool your ride in between split stages – huge stress to get the positions right etc.
I might also add that the more mentally comfortable one can be (stress-free) the better the odds of putting up good #’s
Lesson learned from last season.

jonathan

Plus let’s face it, we all spend a lot of time on our bikes, we want something that is aesthetically pleasing. My bike was more expensive than my (very used) car. But I put more mileage on my bike than on my car last year, so I think it’s justified.

Alex R

For a TT, you can buy some speed. A disk wheel and aero bars will make a difference in your times. For other races where drafting makes up so much of the race, you are better off spending your cash on a coach.

ginsu

this is why i hate the tt. not because it hurts so much or because i suck at it but because so many people get caught up in watts, heart rate, equipment, drag coeficients, sub lactate intervals, and so many other things that distract them from cold hard facts.

Steve

The Uk is the Island of TT’s. Most bike competition in the UK is TT, south of London you can probably choose to ride to at least 3 each weekend. Most bike racers are TT’ers and there are a hell of a lot of expensive bikes being ridden by all types.
I stuck clip on aerobars on my road bike and took an average of 1min off my 10mile TT time.
Still if I trained for them, rode them properly etc I would probably lose another 2 mins or so. Still have some of the best TT’rs coming by me on their winter hack machines complete with toe clips and mudguards.!!!! Great!

kwk

if you really want to see some really slow people riding on some way too expensive bikes that make them just a bit faster than my hairy legged brother, go to a local triathalon, it is a total freak show.

ginsu

i read that the hed tri spoke wheels main draw back is that if you can not ride above 40 kph average it is slower that a conventional wheel. is that true?

MH

Your position on the bike is more important than how tricked-out your equipment is. If you have a cheap, heavy TT rig that sets you up in a fast position, and you train on it so you’re comfortable and efficient, you’ll go faster than someone on a $12,000 Pinarello with disk wheel who takes it out of the closet the day before the race. The reason for getting a TT bike is not because the bike itself is so much faster than your road bike, but because you need to adapt your position, and you’re not going to bother if you have to adjust your saddle, seatpost, stem, and handlebars every time you want to go for a training ride.

Aero wheels are probably worth some time, though Jeff King did 27-something in the park last year with a road bike, clip-ons, and a set of Ksyriums, and Alex Gulla did the same the year before.

The first TT I ever did was at Fitchburg in 2003. I borrowed a set of clip-ons the night before, stuck them on my bike and warmed up on the trainer, then headed to the line. I had never tried riding like that on the road, and after a couple of minutes I found I couldn’t breathe. I rode the rest of the TT on the drops.

It’s too bad there’s no TTs in the park this year. In past years Andy posted photographs of everybody, and it was interesting to see what the fast guys look like when they’re racing, and compare it to your own position.

Jeff King

Matt is so nice to me on nyv posts. Now I feel bad for flaming him on the food section. Matt, You’re not as evil as everybody says you are. You’re more like that mini evil guy.

actually....

Gulla was low 26’s but he did have a disk wheel on his stell bianchi with clip on bars.

TS

You can buy speed, but that will only make you a faster slow person or a faster fast person. Nothing replaces the engine. Position and equipment help, but only so much. Now, if you are trying to improve within a certain range, buy away. Last year I lost 2nd place in 2 tts by 1 sec. I missed out on 1st by 6 secs. I won a tt by 1.5 secs. When it is as tight as this, I am hunting for seconds wherever I can find them – helmet, shoe covers made of wind laminate stuff instead of permeable lycra, bolt-on skewers, 19mm tires, creative cable routing, ect. I won’t go so far as to shave my arms. And the shoulder is sacrosanct. This is on top of the bike/wheel choices that are standard – disk, aero frame, tt bars. Does riding your bike a ton help? Probably but John Loehner got 6th in the National TT champs in 92 on a bike he borrowed just before the event. Like I said. It’s all about the engine – Might makes right. In 02 in the North Atlantic TT champs, Mike Dietrich – now a pro on Sierra Nevada – took 4th in 53:27 on a road bike with clipons and spoked wheels.

Anonymous

as you imply by bringing up the equipment argument right after the sandbaggin argument, these are both symptoms of dragon as$ complex.

i didn’t win b/c of a sandbagger
i didn’t win b/c my equipment sucks
i didn’t win b/c my [INSERT VO2/LT/AT/ANY OTHER QUASI-UNDERSTOOD METRIC HERE] is too low/high
i didn’t win b/c my energy drink didn’t have protein
&c.

this keeps people buying more schnitz, to which i say, cool. if you got money in your pocket to go buy some theoretical speed, go buy it. supports the bike store/catalog/industry. gets the velocity of your dollar up and into someone else’s mitts. keep making more dough and spreading it around, the more money you spend the bigger cycling will get. trickle down effect in action. plus psychologically easier to swallow than saying to yourself ‘i blow goats,’ and don’t underestimate the frailty of a man’s ego in full-on lycra and the mental health importance of proppin up said ego by any means.

so the next time you see a tri-freak on a tricked-out P3 kicking it at 19mph, thank him/her. just as the lottery is a tax on those who are bad at math, good equipment is a tax on the weaker riders. they’re subsidizing your portion of development costs.

FULL DISCLOSURE: i just ordered a boatload of protein-laden energy drink. my energy drink is the sole reason i don’t win races, nothing else. i will keep searching until i find the right one. this undying belief in the incompetence of my energy drink provides the full psychological benefit of an equipment addiction at a fraction of the cost. next stop: colostrum from virgin new zealand cows.

kevin molloy

What ever happened to 40ks??

Granted you could get dizzy if there were more laps, but 11.5 miles was the junior 14/15 distance at the 1986 CT state TT championships.

ps, i don’t even own a pr of aero bars, i think a Merckx competition would be cool.

JT

If you go the thrifty route of TT’ing on your road bike, do what you can to make the switch of set-up easy. One thing is to get a second seat and seatpost for TTs and mark them and the road post/seat. Then you can just pull one out fast and put the other in with no measuring.

lee3

There was a cannibal TT in NJ already. I think they called it the Flanders TT. (not sure)
Another factor to consider, when reading the TS post, is that the course will usually dictate the set-up. The Dietrich time you posted didnt describe the parcours. Was it hilly? Perhaps his set-up made sense. The Loehner case is plausible. Most athletes with time to calibrate a comfortable position and time to warm-up are capable of good results. Not to belittle the accomplishments of the rider you mentioned, but I’ve seen guys post good times on borrowed bikes and new unfamiliar bikes. That said I also agree with your point about the engine. All flash and no gas sucks. If you have the equipment atleast put in the work.

TS

Dietrich did his time on a rolling course – the CT TT course in Winstead that goes up Rte. 8 into MA. It is fast. Full aero is best on that course. Kevin, where you there in ’86? I raced that day.

jonathan

ok so the rig makes a little weency bit of a difference in a TT…
what about road bikes? (I know this is a little redundant to the "dream bike" comparo last week)

lee3

c’mon – half the fun is the cool gear!! I cant think of any other sport with the coolest gear! A climbing bike, TT, road sword, and the (winter / Battenkill Roubaix) rig. It satisfies the the tech-geek in all of us – no bitching here!

PROSPECT PARK

No name in search of energy drink have you tried Andrews cup cakes, I hear it helped him win last night

bcthree

About 9 years ago when the whole Carbon craze started and road bikes didn’t have the strict laws that they do know. I saw a cat.2 race with a 5 man break away, 4 guys from the same team with tricked out Monocarbon bikes (similar to the old trek "Y" frame), and the 5th guy was on a 70’s Pogliaghi. He was shifting on the down tubes, feet strapped in. Not only did he fly from his breakaway group… not only did he lap the field… he crossed the finish line first and caught the breakaway group doing so! You should have seen there face when they saw they where a lap behind this guy. From that day on I knew it’s all about the one on the machine and not so much the machine!

But… on the other side of things a TT bike does make a difference, and so does a good set of wheels. Just don’t doubt the guy that put in the work at the end of the day. Someone that can drop 10G on a bike ain’t going to be able to turn over a 55*12 if they don’t have the muscle or heart! (still working on turning that one over!)

Anonymous

No point in bringing up Gulla and his rig. The guy was a freak. He could ride circles around every CRCA member except Loehner and Upton.

JT

I don’t understand the interest or desire to ride a "cannibal" TT. I can understand perhaps having some training TTs where the expensive stuff like disk wheels are not allowed. That could level the playing field. But getting into a serious TT position — with clip-ons or dedicated aero bars — is a fundamental part of the sport that, in the big scheme of things, not that expensive. In fact aero bars are probably the cheapest speed you can buy, and finding a good position in that takes skill and practice. Those are things our sport should reward.

Littlefield

Quote of the day:
"I blow goats"
Classic. I’m thinking of having that painted on my top tube.

kevin molloy

JT – sure the stuff is cheap, but you know the riding position is significantly different and you need to train in that position to make it effective. so given the impact of TT’s on racing results throughout the year time seems best spent focusing on the road position for me.

besides, i’d much rather have a set of 28 spoke GEL 280’s with campy SR hubs tied and soldered than a carbon disk wheel!

TS – yes the same course, nice and "rolly". best i could muster was a 59:09, no aero bars 32 spoke matrix iso rims in the 40k in ’88??

out of respect for all the great racers in our club, don’t judge gulla’s TT time as the be all/end all indicator of his racing ability. you overlook a lot of other guys who could dismantle him on a regular basis in a typical road race or crit. sherry, x-factor, upton, lattanzi, gavi, loehner, eugene, etc, etc. actually, then again i don’t think gulla would be racing with these guys b/c he’s not a 2

Craig Cook

I gotta say, it’s funny Schmaltz is the posterboy for this bit. His position is terrible. There’s a shot from Floyd yesterday and apart from lacking clip-ons, the positon is basically the same as the one above. Schmaltz my boy, plane yourself out a bit will ya? 3 inches down and 2 out would make more of a difference than all the aerogear combined. C2

Andy

Craig, Schmalz is here to be mocked. More of a whipping boy than a poster boy. Of course, I’m stating the obvious.

schmalz

I always thought the rule of thumb for TT position was to use the same position you use to move your bowels…

Justin

Hey Kev,

Not looking to stir up controversy and certainly not looking to disparage anyone in the club but I don’t remember Alex being "dismantled on a regular basis" by alot of club members. I do remember him soloing a Team Cup race in his first attempt, I do remember him riding away from pretty much the entire Blue Ribbon team (when they were 3’s) in the hilly New York State Champs, I do remember him winning – again solo – the Massachusetts State Champs and I do remember him winning the bronze medal in the ESG again by simply riding off the front for much of the race. In fact I also remember an occassion at FBF when Eugene by his own public admission spoke about riding Alex’s wheel for 8 laps and barely holding on before outsprinting him. His own words "the most impressive thing he’s seen in local cycling since Wilson won a SS on a mountain bike"

And as mentioned I do remember him riding 26.08 TT on a steel triple chain ring with clip on bars. He was and if he ever comes back again will be a pretty special talent.

Justin – VB

Craig

Don’t forget the time Gulla raced in the B’s – caught the A field rode right through them caught the A break then dropped them too. Guy was a legend.

Joe

No question some great racers in CRCA could dismantle Gulla in a crit or RR just based on the fact that he wasn’t very savvy or tactically inclined. But pure strength and probably untapped potential and ability to suffer the guy was/is a very unique talent.

Too bad he seems to have lost interest in the sport.

SG

first, variances in budgets and the aerodynamic advantage of a riders’ equipment is, and has always been, part of time trialing. there is no question that the very most important weapon one can possess is fitness, strength both physically and mentally, and the right body physique for good aerodynamics. yet, good equipment shall always be to the advantage of the one who possesses it, and to the detriment of those who dont have or can’t afford it.

lance armstrong, postal and discovery spent significant monies to acquire the best technologies, to get the most aerodynamic setups on their riders’ bikes. was it an advantage? yes. unfair? no. because thats how that game is written.

Recently, there was a flanders TT which was ala eddy merx. the idea was "old school":. no tt bikes, no clipons , no aero bards, no discs. so everyone who hda the means, technology and desire had their stems drilled down lot, water bottle cages removed, and the deepest dish non disc you could get. I finally had a great reason to use my 808s instead of the 999s. (fyi, i am detinately one that is addicted to wheels and loves having many arrows in the quiver.).

if you’re the one in possession you’re in favor of unconstrained rules. if you are not in possession of the technologies, then you’d love it to be like "stock car" racing. unfortunately, stock setsup are not feasible in amateur cycling. heck, they dont even enforce the 5cm saddle setback from bb rule.

i’ve had many racers come to me after my finish and ask to borrow wheels and i’m always glad to do so. remember, at the end of the day, i have to assume, putting money aside, that most of us are addicted to this sport, and even if we cant own it, we love staring at it, marveling at it; TT setups are cutting edge. the edge of speed , aerodynamics and teechnology. and so i would be totally out of favor of eliminating such advantages because it would put us bak in the stone ages, which would have a devistating impact on the overal progression of cycling stuff.

heck, i say lets scrap a stealth bomber or two, take the proceeds and give every registered USCF rider a set of 404s. until then, make do with what you go. find a good set of 404s, very versatile and rock hard.
-sg

MH

Justin: just for the record, at that NY state champs race, Alex was in a 4-man break with two BR guys, one of whom flatted (the weather that day was a lot like this weekend, torrential rain). Then Alex escaped from the others, crashed hard, picked himself up, won with half his shorts torn off. But it might be burnishing the legend too much to say he rode away from our whole team. We had a good situation until Cavallo flatted.

I was in the break that other miserable rainy day in the park when Alex soloed through the As. We had 3 minutes on the field and couldn’t figure out why we were being passed by a moto. Then we saw him come by. I guess you could say he beat everybody that day, though it was another big talent, Aaron Pomeroy, who won the A race.

I seem to remember that Aaron once found a TT bike by the side of the highway. It had fallen off somebody’s car. That might be an apocryphal story, but at least it’s back on topic.

Andy

I think Aaron bought it off a guy who saw it fly off a roof, or something like that. I think it was a state of the art TT bike, for 10 years ago.

Comments are closed.