A quick and dirty review of off-season roller racing, because Andy asked.
by Aaron Wolfe
OK, so there’s not much for a dedicated bike racer to do in the winter, or read, for that matter, judging by the dearth of articles here lately. But for the competition addicts, roller racing can speed the months a bit more quickly than watching all the Lance tours over and over while on the trainer.
The point of roller racing seems to be this for the racer: To test a highly specific skill that can’t really be tested on its own on the road. And for the spectator: To yell and scream, to drink and gamble while perhaps admiring the display of this highly specific skill but at the same time laughing knowing it won’t matter in March.
In fact, the racers could have measured their cadences for 35 seconds at home, away from the indignities of wearing team kits in a packed bar, and phoned in the results. The finishing order would be the same. When it comes to high cadence and jump, either you’ve got it or you don’t. Getting sweaty next to LaCorte in front of a crowd of drunk idiots waving dollar bills won’t help. In this sense, roller racing is BORING.
But satellite roller racing would be even less fun than a self-administered functional threshold test. So there we all are in our kits in a bar. This year we’ve either been at Lulu’s for Goldsprints with fork mounts on rollers hooked up to a computer, or at the 169 Bar for some real roller races using the peerless mechanical racing rollers of Bikeworks.
And what exactly are we doing? The racers jump from a standing start and spin like hell for a specified distance. Pure power matters highly for the first few seconds. Then it’s all form and leg speed in the neuromuscular zone. If the race is long enough anaerobic fitness starts to come into play. Balance is key throughout.
Like most training, you train harder than you race, and gain more fitness from training. So to do a roller race is merely the reward for leg speed training, which will help with road sprinting and comfort/efficiency on the bike.
The numbers go like this: At a sanctioned roller race such as NYVelocity put on, you can usually ride a 51×14 on skinny tires and make the rollout. Top virtual speeds will hit 55-65mph. Cadence probably goes up to 210rpm max. Look at the times and do the math to figure out sustained cadence.
The technique seems to have two schools. Roadies prefer hands on the tops, and trackies like the drops, which indicates that trackies have a greater ability to use their arms and control them perfectly, while roadies look like they could go on comfortably on the tops for some time after the race ends. Less than perfect control lands you on the crash mix on youtube, while endurance gets you nowhere. You can’t be competitive without a fixed gear bike.
Time for hate: If you choose to participate or watch, here’s what you’ll find: Goldsprints at Lulu’s offered a crappy venue with generally awful loud music. You’ll pay for your own drinks, but the hot dogs and admission are free. The racing is soulless and computerized and the fixed-fork bikes are provided in S, M or L (these really make you sore the next day, but you don’t have to ride rollers to race, so anyone can try). There’s no crashing, but there is vomiting. The crowd and most of the competition are all bike hipsters, messengers and the like, and they don’t really understand what you’re doing or why you’re doing it. But the prizes for racers are excellent (like a case of beer, $100 messenger bag and $40 of bike coupons for 2nd place), and the entry fee is low. If you’re lucky it will be over before 1am.
The NYVelocity races had a cramped venue where spendy bikes kept getting knocked over onto each other, but no annoying music–just a drunk MC with junior high humor (a compliment, I’m sure). Free beer makes up for the heat and lack of oxygen, and on your own newly scratched bike there’s less soreness the next day. The crowd will be the cream of the bike hipster crop and all the roadies you know from Central and Prospect parks. They’ll know what you’re doing and why, and they’re laughing at you because they know. Crashers are especially mocked and therefore entries will remain low. You’ll pay to watch or race, and by the time the races are over the free beer will be gone. You’ll race on Bikeworks’ beautiful mechanical race rollers, but get only a pat on the back for a podium prize. Done at 10pm because bike racers have finance jobs in the morning.
Where does that leave us? Uh…try it once for fun, and then continue if you have to.
Aaron, great work and informative article. How come you can’t be competitive "without a fixed gear"? Wouldn’t a road bike with same gear inches work?
The Spillage in the Village
presented by CRCA
December 12, 2006
Bar 169, New York, NY
500m Qualifying Times
Men
1) Andrew Lacorte – 16.81
2) Aaron Wolfe – 17.97
3) Mike Prokopec – 18.66
3) Jon Orcutt – 18.66
5) Kevin Molloy – 18.95
6) David Wiswell – 19.85
7) Lloyd Leary – 20.22
8) Jorma Mueller – 21.62
9) Russell Kelly – 26.72
10) Gui Weinmann – n/t
Women
1) Erin Dyer – 20.72
2) Tara Parsons – 24.03
First Round Sprints (1000 meters)
#5 Molloy def. #6 Wiswell – 36.62
#4 Orcutt def. #7 Leary – no contest
#3 Prokopec def. #8 Mueller – 37.34
#2 Wolfe def. Kelly – 43.59
#1 LaCorte def. #10 Weinmann – no contest
Round 1 Repechage
#9 Kelly def. #8 Mueller – 40.06
#6 Wiswell def. #10 Weinmann – 38.47
Semi-Finals
#5 Molloy def. #4 Orcutt & #3 Prokopec – 36.84
#2 Wolfe def. #6 Wiswell – 36.72
#1 Lacorte def. #9 Kelly – no contest
Finals
#1 Lacorte def. #2 Wolfe & #5 Molloy – 35.09
#1 Dyer def. #2 Parsons – 40.81
Excellent write up Aaron.
Niko – the fixed pushes your leg around the dead spots in the predal stroke. I get a lot of chopping when I spin that fast with a freewheel.
Alex – Old Mil? I got a case of fine Belgian beer.
I’d still take the jersey, I can buy the beer around the corner.
yeah, and your name up in lights. don’t get that at lulu’s
Howbeit that a fixed helps in roller races by pushing the leg around and yet some riders say riding a fixed helps the rider learn to pedal better. I don’t think both can be true. I think the first one is true.
"fixed helps in roller races by pushing the leg around"
If the pedal is pushing on the leg, then the leg is also pushing back. That’s bad, no?
But if you’re sloppy with a freewheel, the "pushback" doesn’t get transferred to the back wheel. That’s better, yes?
Thanks Alan Atwood
You really made the show "official"
We should all thank you for performing
rollouts, timing and race announcing!
I hope you kept your voice
and had a happy good cheer
I thought the advantage to a fix was that you could get the 90" gear spot on?
I think pedaling better at 100rpms and at 200 are not really the same, for me anyway. At 100 it seems possible to push, pull and lift all the way around, like with powercranks. But at 200, i feel that I’m just pushing alternately with each leg as fast as I can. Maybe others can pedal more completely at that cadence, but I haven’t been able to do it.
I thought people say fixeds help pedaling technique because you can’t stop pedaling, and because you sometimes pedal faster than you would normally. In other words, it forces you to practice, which I guess makes fixed a learning tool for pedaling.
Eugene, I would say yes and no to your suggestion. Yes, the leg pushing back is bad because it slows down your leg speed a bit. But ideally your muscles are "off" at that point so it’s not that much pushback. And yes, that is bad for speed compared to having the ability to apply power for 100% of the stroke, but like I said, I don’t think that’s possible, for me anyway. To the freewheel being an advantage, I say no because your legs slow down much more when they "skip" than they would with a fixed. So you lose leg speed and leg momentum.
Anyway, I have no expertise here. These are just my impressions about myself.
You can get the gearing just right on any bike.
True, but people are far less apt to do it on their road bikes as they dont have extra chain wheels and such laying around, as a rule trackies are more obsessed with gearing..
BTW, the 3 men’s finalists (Aaron, Kevin, and LaCupcake) were so closely matched, that they held the same speed throughout the 1k final. Gaps were established from the gun, and then no one pulled ahead or fell behind.
Wake up Eugene, actually watch the video again. Yes, Lacorte got them on the gun but Aaron and Molloy were gaining on Lacorte. But his spotter told him something like they were gaining or something. Lacorte just started to pull away towards the last 200m.
Whoops – that was kind of embarrassing for you there LaCorte ! Posting a self flattery comment as Mike M when you’re already logged in as yourself !. What was I saying about ego earlier.
No ego
Ok, I’m awake! I’ll check out the video.
No, Mike is right. It is the "M" that gave you away jackass. Having fun Mr. Louie?
The answer is Mikem.net okay. Stop messing around.
BTW, Cute Coach, Not embarassed though. But If I had something to say I would love to just tell you, so come out of the closet. I always put my name for the record.
You know it is cute to try to embarass me. So let’s try new ways since that didn’t work, okay?
And Mike, ok "You Win" you dumb ass. But to go out of your way like that was kind of crazy. Don’t you think? LOL, You need help, dude. I figured out how you did it you sick bastard. The messed up thing is that you didn’t have to login to leave a message. You could have signed in as anonymous you stupid ass. Change my profile name back too before I have the last laugh.
Oh, You finally figured it out. Your Navman is in your trunk ontop of the spare… We are cool right? Game over?
No comment. This can get out of hand. That was sick man. Give me a day to think about it.
What the hell is going on here?
Mike, Whats German, black, brand new, and sits on four wheels? I told you don’t play around. You have until noon, December 19. Otherwise I drop it off somewhere in an undisclosed location in the Bronx.
Ok,,, Check your mail box. Where is my ride…?
First, clean up the soup profile first if you want to see it tonight!
OK Done. Everything has been cleared out. Don’t remember what the account info was originally. Where is my ride?
Smitties, keys are in tailpipe.
This is about the wierdest thread ever.