EXCLUSIVE POWERCRANKING?
By Kenneth Lundgren
PowerCranks, if used properly, are a terrific training tool and arguably one of the best things you can do to truly improve performance… I’ve been speaking with a number of riders about them, and they are under the impression that when you train on them, you ride them exclusively. In fact, I was talking to a rider who is doing just that this winter, and I think that is a mistake – although PowerCranks the company even claims you should!!! I was speaking with Mark Alden of the Blue Ribbon Cycling Team, a fierce climber in his own right, and he made a keen observation – that you lose some of your downstroke power after riding them. And I think he makes a good point…
In all honesty, I don’t think PowerCranks drastically increase V02 or anaerobic threshold power. PowerCranks are like EPO (from what I’ve read!) – you don’t put out more power at max effort, you just put out more power for longer periods – staying power, I suppose… At 350w, you just don’t fatigue the same. My 20 and 30-minute maxes have improved over 5%, translating into 18 more watts that I didn’t have before. I can tell you on the time-trial bike, at same Perceived Effort, I am a completely different rider. The times are down and I feel better on the bike, much more economical, always searching for more speed, as if I can’t push hard enough – as if I have a greater bank from which to draw strength.
I agree with Alden regarding the downstroke power. When PowerCranking, you have to pull your leg back and then up. You just cannot implement the powerful up-and-down piston stroke of traditional cranks. Because of this, I would recommend NOT riding the Cranks exclusively. I notice that when I ride the Cranks hard for a day, the next day on my traditional cranks at first my cadence is a little choppy – I’m pulling up and it feels unnatural. If you ride the Cranks for an extended block and avoid the regular bike, you may be in a jam… You need to jump back and forth between natural cranks and PowerCranks and work them together. March is not the time to hop back on the road bike and expect to resume the necessary training!
I would recommend riding the Cranks two times a week all winter – say Wednesday and Saturday or Sunday, trying to work them around your lifting schedule. The hammies, the hip flexors, these are smaller muscles that need strong recovery after being exhausted. Riding them a TON week after week can lead to plateau or degeneration – as with everything, you should follow a logical plan. Tempo and force work, as well as cadence drills, are essential winter-time focuses and PowerCranks really allow you to hit these areas perfectly.
Just “riding†the PowerCranks will help you become more economical, and you’ll see improvements, but you should tailor PowerCrank training to your goals and objectives. Road racers, all-arounders, climbers, time-trialists, and sprinters should all use them differently.
As we’re in the gym working a progressive weight program, which hopefully is geared to your strengths and goals (a sprinter and time-trialist will have two different programs), you should also progress using the PowerCranks. Early in the Foundation block, cadence and pedaling efficiency work should be focus. Cadence drills on the Cranks are murder, but they are excellent low-stress prep for the harder work to come, which include force drills and tempo sessions. As a time-trialist, I do steadier, longer work on them. As the weeks progress, a typical PowerCrank ride will include a few 5-minute threshold Power Climbs at 65-75 rpms. Another session may include longer, 15-20-minute Tempo intervals, just steady eddy in that steady golden zone over rolling terrain. Typically, I try to do a quality ride on TT bike the first day, then hit the PowerCranks the day after. For me, this seems to work best, but everyone is different and you have to find what works.
For you sprinters out there, try sprinkling in PowerCrank sprint drills. Developing a solid sprint takes considerable time, and specific sprint work should be a year-round mainstay. You should NOT be starting sprint work as you progress through Build weeks. Also, I should add, doing sprints – whether it’s big-gear sprints, “stuck†sprints (mildly overgeared), uphill sprints, or high-speed sprints – are borderline impossible on the Cranks without a super-strong core. You really learn to balance the body and involve more upper body in the movement. Of course, to involve the upper body we need the core, so as we strengthen the core in the winter, look to incorporate these improved lower back and abdominal muscles for increased power. Sprinting is just not leg power and leg speed. Mixing up the sprint sessions between the traditional and PowerCranks will result in a much improved sprinting prowess…
Doing one group every other week is great for the later stages of Foundation training, as you can maintain pack-riding skills and get some mild anaerobic work. I would recommend alternating group riding between the traditional bike and the PowerCranks bike. If you opt to do a group ride every week, then one week sit in and ride steadier with the Cranks, and the second week use the road bike to complete the more specific work. If you’re a sprinter, go for the sprints. If you’re a time-trialist, do the steady, long pulls. If your strength is V02 max efforts, gas it for 2 minutes up the climbs. Once every 14 days or so, it’s important to open it up while still finishing the ride feeling fresh…
In closing, try to round out your training COMPLETELY… Too much of one thing (i.e. exclusive PowerCranking) can derail your training. I personally use the PowerCranks to strengthen my strength, but you can use them to improve all aspects of your riding. At the end of the day, you just want to make sure all the hard work is worth something when the stars start to shine…
ELITE ENDURANCE TRAINING SYSTEMS
www.EliteEndurance.com
I don’t have the energy.
I was reading about this Serotta “cycling science” meeting (on Velonews: http://velonews.com/article/71634) recently, and one of the findings struck me:
“Finally, Martin
By my count we’re due for a helmet debate before a powercrank one.
use this opportunity to talk about something positive instead of arguing about moot points. You’re not going to change anyone’s mind with your lame discussions. We’re all smart enough to make our own informed decisions.
Isn’t anyone excited about something…? Share it.
i’m pretty excited about the used powercranks i picked up recently on ebay. the first time on them my legs were cooked in less than 5 mins. two weeks later i’m doing 30min sessions in the mornings turning pretty big gears. i haven’t checked my wattage increases (will probably give it another month for that) but i can feel the core strength building as well as strength throughout the entire pedal stroke. i have no idea how this will work out but i’m willing to experiment on it this season.
That VN article is certainly worth reading in that it has two ‘scientific’ studies coming to opposing conclusions on foot canting, thus clearly demonstrating that at least half these people don’t know what they’re talking about.
Personally, if I had to give up the powermeter or the powercranks, I’d lose the meter and just train by HR/ speed/ RPE.
Three years ago, trying to reduce outside knee pain from a mistracking patella, I was advised to try to increase the use of the muscles on the inside of the leg (i.e., VMO). I took 3 Lemond wedges and canted my foot inward (as per the new work by Hull) rather than the conventional canting outward as proposed by Pruitt. This rather quickly eliminated the pain in my left knee and it has never come back (still have that foot canted). Soon after, I developed the same pain in my right knee and canting my right foot inward has reduced, but not completely eliminated the pain on the outside of that knee (most rides no pain and some rides mild to moderate discomfort that usually goes away during the ride).
P=Crankers to have a separate field yet?
Cat 4 field 75% full!
Great idea, two sprints a lap will be epic!
Power Points Races
Points awarded at top of Harlem Hill on every lap except the first
Points awarded at the finish line on every lap
Points awarded at the finish on the final lap
JUST STOP IT ALREADY WITH THE POWER CRANKS!
There was a recent article on an elite lady triathlete or time trialist (can’t remember) and it was written that her saddle was moved back and not forward as is commonly done for TT events. She was apparently able to make better use of her strong hamstring muscles and quads with her saddle back. This is what Ken also says in this article emphasizing working on your strenghs. I’ve heard that powercranks are really hard on your behind, is this true?
Well if Ken Harris has given up on power cranks, we all must give up on them. He has spoken.
You should never have knee pain. muscular imbalances can be fixed off the bike, and a real pedal fit helps tremendously, wedges only mask the real problem, you’re not fit properly.
You failed reading comprehension. Now go get a helmet and some powercranks.
and Paul Levine at Signature using spin scan and dartfish. Neither fitter wanted to remove my wedges. Now there’s some research (Hull) to support inward canting.
Before using the wedges I could ride for about 35 minutes before I was in too much pain too continue. Using the wedges, I enjoy cycling again, I can train as much as I want and enough to race, I did well on the spin scan pedaling analysis, and there has been no secondary issues resulting from the use of the wedges.
You’re right. I’ll take them out and look for another answer to the problem.
I wish someone could tell the guys in charge of the mirrors on the GWB to set them up in such a way that you don’t see yourself but oncoming cyclists. I always look up and see this fat guy approaching and only after almost riding off the bridge to avoid him do I realize that it’s me I’m seeing. I’ve stopped a few times to change the angle but then the guard think that I am a terrorist and gets very uptight. Maybe if we could all ask the guards to change the mirrors or get off and do it ourselves it would make a difference.
well if CRAIG UPTON fit you, its gotta be right….
reading comprehension is overrated man.
are overrated
are pretty fairly valued, actually
they’re just bored at work frustrated that they can’t get paid today and have to wait until monday.
I have a used, but good set of Powercranks, 175mm in length, campy 135 bolt pattern, 53-39, which I will include a campy record square taper BB (english thread) for the great price of $300. contact me via email if interested: blakeacre@yahoo.com
I heard how tough PC’s were and most people can only ride a short time. A friend of mine purchased them and he let me try them. Hopped on them and went on 20mile ride(only had a short time available) and felt fine the next day. No soreness..nothing. I think they could be a good training tool but if your pedal stroke is pretty good already….may not be time well spent..or money for that matter.
I heard how tough PC’s were and most people can only ride a short time. A friend of mine purchased them and he let me try them. Hopped on them and went on 20mile ride(only had a short time available) and felt fine the next day. No soreness..nothing. I think they could be a good training tool but if your pedal stroke is pretty good already….may not be time well spent..or money for that matter.
I have a used, but good set of Powercranks, 175mm in length, campy 135 bolt pattern, 53-39, which I will include a campy record square taper BB (english thread) for the great price of $300. contact me via email if interested: blakeacre@yahoo.com
they’re just bored at work frustrated that they can’t get paid today and have to wait until monday.
well if CRAIG UPTON fit you, its gotta be right….
reading comprehension is overrated man.
are overrated
are pretty fairly valued, actually
if someone getting dropped is the criterion for determing a product doesn’t work….
..we should all quit the sport. We all suck
“I wish someone could tell the guys in charge of the mirrors on the GWB…”
Should be called “kill! Wanna kill!” races in honor of kwk
Adjusting the mirrors would require them to shut down the south walk until April.
when you got dropped in phillipsburg last year?
I wish someone could tell the guys in charge of the mirrors on the GWB to set them up in such a way that you don’t see yourself but oncoming cyclists. I always look up and see this fat guy approaching and only after almost riding off the bridge to avoid him do I realize that it’s me I’m seeing. I’ve stopped a few times to change the angle but then the guard think that I am a terrorist and gets very uptight. Maybe if we could all ask the guards to change the mirrors or get off and do it ourselves it would make a difference.
Before using the wedges I could ride for about 35 minutes before I was in too much pain too continue. Using the wedges, I enjoy cycling again, I can train as much as I want and enough to race, I did well on the spin scan pedaling analysis, and there has been no secondary issues resulting from the use of the wedges.
You’re right. I’ll take them out and look for another answer to the problem.
and Paul Levine at Signature using spin scan and dartfish. Neither fitter wanted to remove my wedges. Now there’s some research (Hull) to support inward canting.
You failed reading comprehension. Now go get a helmet and some powercranks.
You should never have knee pain. muscular imbalances can be fixed off the bike, and a real pedal fit helps tremendously, wedges only mask the real problem, you’re not fit properly.
Well if Ken Harris has given up on power cranks, we all must give up on them. He has spoken.
JUST STOP IT ALREADY WITH THE POWER CRANKS!
There was a recent article on an elite lady triathlete or time trialist (can’t remember) and it was written that her saddle was moved back and not forward as is commonly done for TT events. She was apparently able to make better use of her strong hamstring muscles and quads with her saddle back. This is what Ken also says in this article emphasizing working on your strenghs. I’ve heard that powercranks are really hard on your behind, is this true?
P=Crankers to have a separate field yet?
Cat 4 field 75% full!
Great idea, two sprints a lap will be epic!
Power Points Races
Points awarded at top of Harlem Hill on every lap except the first
Points awarded at the finish line on every lap
Points awarded at the finish on the final lap
Three years ago, trying to reduce outside knee pain from a mistracking patella, I was advised to try to increase the use of the muscles on the inside of the leg (i.e., VMO). I took 3 Lemond wedges and canted my foot inward (as per the new work by Hull) rather than the conventional canting outward as proposed by Pruitt. This rather quickly eliminated the pain in my left knee and it has never come back (still have that foot canted). Soon after, I developed the same pain in my right knee and canting my right foot inward has reduced, but not completely eliminated the pain on the outside of that knee (most rides no pain and some rides mild to moderate discomfort that usually goes away during the ride).
That VN article is certainly worth reading in that it has two ‘scientific’ studies coming to opposing conclusions on foot canting, thus clearly demonstrating that at least half these people don’t know what they’re talking about.
Personally, if I had to give up the powermeter or the powercranks, I’d lose the meter and just train by HR/ speed/ RPE.
i’m pretty excited about the used powercranks i picked up recently on ebay. the first time on them my legs were cooked in less than 5 mins. two weeks later i’m doing 30min sessions in the mornings turning pretty big gears. i haven’t checked my wattage increases (will probably give it another month for that) but i can feel the core strength building as well as strength throughout the entire pedal stroke. i have no idea how this will work out but i’m willing to experiment on it this season.
use this opportunity to talk about something positive instead of arguing about moot points. You’re not going to change anyone’s mind with your lame discussions. We’re all smart enough to make our own informed decisions.
Isn’t anyone excited about something…? Share it.
By my count we’re due for a helmet debate before a powercrank one.
I was reading about this Serotta “cycling science” meeting (on Velonews: http://velonews.com/article/71634) recently, and one of the findings struck me:
“Finally, Martin
I don’t have the energy.
Is anyone here anymore? for that matter, even using PC’s anymore, or has all the hub-bub died down ’bout them now?